Blog Layout

Defiant and difficult: the kids who *HATE* being told what to do

Ceara Deno, MD • June 23, 2023
Schedule A Free Call

For some kids, being told what to do is the ABSOLUTE WORST

Do you have a kid who *HATES* being told what to do? 

Who refuses to cooperate with even MINOR requests? 

Who won’t do anything unless it's HER idea?


We call these kids STRONG-WILLED. 


What few parents realize, however, is the huge amount of overlap between sensitive and strong-willed kids.  What few parents realize is that when sensitive kids are upset or stressed, they become incredibly STRONG-WILLED as a defense mechanism. 


****


When I was 9, my family took a trip to Disney with a group of relatives. One morning, the kids wore matching Disney shirts for a photo. In the picture, we are happily beaming wearing our matching shirts—except my sister, who is around 4 years old, wearing a different shirt and looking absolutely furious. 


Even as a 4 year old, my sister was not going to be controlled by someone else’s agenda, or the need for social conformity. This is a strong-willed kid--one with a strong need for autonomy who will not easily bend to authority. 


****


Most humans dislike being told what to do. That’s pretty normal. When we don’t have control, we feel powerless, unheard, unseen, unvalued. 


For some kids, this feels unpleasant. But for other kids, it feels like death. It’s completely unbearable. 


Maybe you have a kid like this. Maybe you know how really, really challenging this becomes. 


****


Sensitive kids are often rigid, inflexible, defiant and stubborn when pressured. They dig in their heels. They’re persistent. Insistent.  Intense.  Determined.  Dogged. 


If you have a kid like this, it can be a MAJOR PAIN IN THE YOU-KNOW-WHAT this can be when you are simply trying to get through the week. 



Sensitive kids become defiant and difficult as a defense because: 


*they want to feel safe in a world that so often feels overwhelming and overstimulating


*they cling to their comfort zone, since they struggle so much with unknowns, newness or change


*they refuse to try new things so they won't possibly "fail"--since their harsh inner critic defines anything less than perfection as "failure"


****


What happens when our sensitive kid becomes defiant when we’ve asked them to do something?   We dig our heels in, too.


We apply pressure. We explain why they have no choice. We explain why we're right (and they're wrong). 

We use logic to explain our perspective. We use threats to increase our authority. Unfortunately, none of these are likely to help our child be more cooperative and flexible. 


Applying pressure will actually make a strong-willed or sensitive kid dig in their heels more. 

How do we change this? How do we create cooperation and flexibility? 


We become more relationship-focused. We become curious. We tackle the problem like a team. We create connection. We use playfulness and lessen up on control. We stop caring so much about compliance and obedience--and we start caring about understanding and compassion. 


If this resonates, if you have a strong-willed or sensitive child and you’d love to see more cooperation and flexibility in them, schedule a free call with me by clicking the link below.  In the call, you will get clarity on how to create a more harmonious, peaceful home with your strong-willed or sensitive kid. 


Click here to a consultation




By Ceara Deno, MD February 21, 2025
As parents, it can be very unsettling when children lie to us. While lying is a very normal part of childhood development, there are reasons that highly sensitive children may be more prone to lying. And so we want to look underneath the behavior to better understand why they are struggling to tell the truth. Also, how we respond will make a difference as to whether our child is able to tell the truth in the future.
By Ceara Deno, M.D. February 11, 2025
Have you ever thought, “If only my partner would parent differently, life would be so much easier?” You’re not alone. Parenting differences are incredibly common--and incredibly frustrating. Especially when raising a highly sensitive child. The good news? You don’t have to agree on everything to be an amazing team. Instead of trying to change your partner, try these three strategies to create more harmony: ​ ​ 1️⃣ Get Curious, Not Combative Instead of reacting with frustration, try asking, “Help me understand what's most important to you in this situation?” Your partner has a good reason for what they do as a parent. When we assume good intentions, and seek to understand, we are more likely to get good will and openness in return. Most parenting comes from a place of deep love. When we understand our partner’s heart and thinking, we are more likely to find areas of common ground. ​ 2️⃣ Appreciate the Balance Parenting differences can actually benefit children! Parenting differences can be complementary. Different perspectives makes the family system stronger. Think of the differences like having different types of tools in a toolbox, rather than having a hammer only. With diverse tools, you can fix more things than if you only had a hammer. ​ 3️⃣ Lead by Example The best way to influence your partner’s parenting? Show, don’t tell. When one parent can stay calm during a meltdown, or hold a peaceful boundary—the other partner is way more likely to adopt what works. When children respond positively, your partner will be noticing. Leading by example is incredibly powerful. ​ ****************** ​ Would you love to be on the same parenting page with your partner or coparent? Would you love a more peaceful, connected home? Let’s talk. Together, I’d love to help you and/or your partner break patterns that aren’t serving you and your family. Maybe you’d like to be better at staying calm and not losing your temper. Maybe your partner wants to do this. Maybe you’re fighting with your kids over every little thing. Maybe your preschooler only wants one parent, and you’re not sure how to change this pattern. Whatever the challenge is, I’d love to help create a more peaceful home for you and your family.
By Ceara Deno, MD February 3, 2025
Parents, I see you--beating yourself up. Criticizing your parenting. Feeling like a failure. I get it. I know you have impossibly high standards for yourself. Y ou want to be PERFECT. You want to get it right, the first time, every time, as a parent. I get it. You care so much, and your heart is so big and strong. Then, when you aren’t perfect, which, newsflash, WILL HAPPEN, you make it mean that you’re failing. That you’re not good enough. But this story is NOT THE TRUTH ABOUT YOU AS A PARENT. Yes, you are imperfect. (Like every person to ever exist.) And, yes, you will make mistakes. (Like every person to ever exist​.) ​ But you are lovable and perfect in your imperfection, like your child. You are learning and making mistakes, like your child. You deserve compassion and love, like your child. You can learn and grow and change, like your child. ​************ If you’re ready to ditch the guilt and shame as a parent, and grow in self-compassion and love, we should chat. I know how easy it is to judge yourself and create a shame story about yourself. But the pressure this creates doesn’t serve you, your child, or your relationship. If you’re ready to ditch the guilt and create more self-compassion, love and connection, I’d love to help. If you’re ready to hold yourself with more gentleness and understanding, let’s schedule a free call together, and create a plan for you to have more peace and connection in your home.
By Ceara Deno, MD January 27, 2025
When you and your child have a blow-up, where there was explosive anger, or you behaved in ways you regret as a parent, it can damage the relationship unless we understand how to repair afterwards. This involves taking responsibility for our part in the conflict, recommitting to the relationship, and collaborative problem-solving around what we can do differently next time.
A close up of a little girl 's face smiling.
By Ceara Deno, MD January 21, 2025
When kids are rude, it’s easy to think they are intentionally trying to be difficult and defiant. But kids are rarely rude for the reasons we think. Instead, rudeness is typically a defense against more vulnerable feelings, like pain and overwhelm. By helping kids open up, we can typically stop rudeness and help them express feelings in healthier ways.
By Ceara Deno, MD January 14, 2025
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.
By Ceara Deno, MD January 3, 2025
Defiance can be one of the most challenging behaviors for parents to navigate. When your highly sensitive child digs in their heels or refuses to cooperate, it’s easy to feel frustrated or unsure of what to do. But it’s important to remember that defiance is often a signal that your child is overwhelmed, scared, or struggling to express their needs. Here are 5 tips for handling defiance with your highly sensitive child.
By Ceara Deno, MD December 30, 2024
Highly sensitive kids thrive with a more gentle kind of discipline, rather than traditional strategies like time-outs or threats. Positive discipline teaches kids the skills they need to manage their emotions, make good decisions, and grow into confident, compassionate individuals. By focusing on connection, empathy, and problem-solving, you can guide your highly sensitive child in a way that strengthens your bond and builds their emotional resilience.
By Ceara Deno, MD December 19, 2024
For sensitive families, the holidays can feel like a lot. There can be a lot of overwhelm from the busy schedule, social gatherings, travel and more. If you are feeling stressed as a parent, you are not alone. Here’s what can help lower your stress level and increase your family’s joy during the holidays.
By Ceara Deno, MD December 10, 2024
If you’re raising a highly sensitive child, you’ve probably noticed how much they thrive on predictability. Change, newness, or surprises can often trigger inflexibility, meltdowns, oppositional behavior and anxiety. By creating predictable routines, we can create more peaceful, connected homes for highly sensitive kids and their families.
More Posts
Share by: